Oliver Nelson/Lou Donaldson - Back Talk

AllMusic Review by Ken Dryden  [-]

This two-record set combines two seemingly unrelated sessions recorded for Cadet in the early '60s. The earlier session features Oliver Nelson leading a large ensemble made of veterans like Phil Woods, Jerome Richardson, Grady Tate, and Snooky Young, while Patti Bown makes the best of a rather out-of-tune piano. Nelson contributed the arrangements and most of the songs, except for Billy Taylor's "A Bientot," which features the leader's powerful tenor sax, and the somewhat gospel-flavored "Daylie's Double," written by Audrey Nelson, the leader's spouse. Some of the tracks might have benefited from additional takes, as Nelson's playing is occasionally a bit sloppy in places, especially on a remake of "Teenie's Blues." This disc was originally issued under the title Fantabulous. The second LP is by Lou Donaldson, originally issued separately as Rough House Blues, with arrangements by Nelson. Woods and Tate are also on this date (as is the little-known tenor saxophonist Robert Ashton), with organist Lloyd Mayers Jr., baritone saxophonist Danny Bank, and trumpeter Ernie Royal among the key players. Aside from a lively take of "Tippin' In" and an imaginatively voiced treatment of "Days of Wine and Roses," the leader wrote all of the songs for the date. The spirit of the church also comes through in "Back Talk," where Donaldson's alto sax seems to be preaching a sermon supported by the band as his choir. One drawback from this session is the rather muddy sound of Mayers' organ. Later reissued by Green Line in Europe without the liner notes or personnel listings, this compilation is worth purchasing in spite of the rather insipid cover photo with a rear view of a nude African-American couple; one is tempted to ask why neither band is featured playing "Cheek to Cheek."

Vinyl Rip From The Double Compilation LP Album (1976)
Release Date
 October 17, 1990


Fantabulous (1964)
01.Hobo Flats [0:00] 02.Post No Bills [4:13] 03.A Bientot [9:42] 04.Three Plus One [13:28] 05.Take Me With You [16:53] 06.Daylie's Double [22:21] 07.Teenie's Blues [26:20] 08.Laz-ie Kate [30:27] Rough House Blues (1966) 09.Tippin' in [34:28] 10.L.D. Blues [39:52] 11.Days Of Wine And Roses [43:07] 12.Ignant Oil [47:34] 13.Rough House Blues [52:32] 14.Back Talk [59:08] 15.Huffin' n Puffin' [1:03:10] OLIVER NELSON : arranged (AB) LOU DONALDSON : alto sax (B) PHIL WOODS : alto sax, clarinet (B) TONY STUDD : bass trombone (A) GRADY TATE : drums (AB) JEROME RICHARDSON : baritone sax, flute (A) BEN TUCKER : bass (A) RICHARD DAVIS : bass (B) LLOYD MAYERS : organ (B) ROY WIEGAND : trombone (A) KENNY SODERBLOM : alto sax, flute (A) ROBERT ASHTON : tenor sax, clarinet (A) ERNIE ROYAL : trumpet (B) SNOOKY YOUNG : trumpet (A) ART HOYLE : trumpet (A) DAVE BURNS : trumpet (B) PATTI BROWN : piano (A)